💬 Let’s Talk Numbers: Just Jack’s Guide to Negotiating the Purchase Price

Just Jack • August 14, 2025

Hey there—Just Jack here!



Let’s be real: whether you're a first-time buyer or you’ve done this a few times before, negotiating the purchase price of a home can feel overwhelming. But guess what? You don’t have to do it alone. I’ve helped plenty of clients in Indiana navigate this part of the deal, and I’m here to help you do the same—with confidence and strategy.


Let’s break it down together.

Couple hugging in a new home, celebrating. Boxes and furniture around, window with sunlight.

🧭 Step 1: Know the Market Before You Make a Move


Before we even talk numbers, it’s critical to understand the current local market conditions. Are we in a seller’s market (high demand, low inventory), a buyer’s market (lots of inventory, less competition), or something more balanced?

📍 In Indiana, market conditions can shift town to town—even neighborhood to neighborhood. That’s why I’ll always give you up-to-date local data, comps (comparable home sales), and insight before we write that first offer.


Jack’s Tip: If a home has been sitting for a while with no offers, we may have more room to negotiate. But if it just hit the market and has five other interested buyers, we may need to get creative with terms instead of focusing just on price.

💰 Step 2: Start with a Smart, Strategic Offer


You don’t want to lowball and risk offending the seller, but you also don’t want to overpay. That’s where experience (and me!) comes in.

Together, we’ll consider:

  • How long the home has been on the market
  • Seller’s motivation (Are they relocating quickly? Downsizing? Already bought another home?)
  • Recent sales of similar homes nearby
  • Any updates or repairs the home may need

From there, we’ll craft a starting offer that reflects market value, leaves room for negotiation, and protects your interests.


Jack’s Tip: It’s not always about price. Sometimes, adjusting things like your closing date, offering flexible move-in terms, or increasing earnest money can give your offer a competitive edge—even if you’re coming in a bit under asking.

🔍 Step 3: Use the Inspection to Your Advantage


Let’s say your offer is accepted—congrats! But we’re not done yet.

After your home inspection, we may discover needed repairs or issues. This is often the next opportunity to negotiate:

  • Ask for repairs to be completed before closing
  • Request a seller credit at closing so you can handle the fixes yourself
  • Re-negotiate the price if the repairs are more than expected
Jack’s Tip: Keep your cool during this phase. The inspection isn’t a wishlist—focus on safety and big-ticket items like the roof, plumbing, foundation, or HVAC. These are the kinds of things sellers will take seriously.

📝 Step 4: Always Get Everything in Writing


Verbal promises mean nothing in real estate—everything needs to be written into the contract. I’ll make sure any negotiated changes (repairs, credits, price reductions, etc.) are legally documented and clearly understood by all parties.


Jack’s Tip: Don’t assume anything is “understood.” I’m here to double-check every detail and make sure nothing gets lost in translation.

🤝 Step 5: Know When to Walk Away (and When to Stand Firm)



Negotiation is a dance—and sometimes, the best move is stepping back.

If the seller won’t budge and the deal doesn’t feel right, you’re allowed to walk away. There are always other homes, and the right one won’t come with regret attached.

That said, if it’s the one, and we’re close to a fair deal, sometimes giving a little can get you a whole lot in return.


Jack’s Tip: I’ll never push you to make a move that doesn’t sit right with you. I’m here to advise, negotiate fiercely on your behalf, and keep your best interests at the heart of every decision.


💡 Final Thoughts from Just Jack


Negotiating the price of a home doesn’t have to feel like a battle. With the right information, timing, and an experienced agent on your side (hi, that’s me!), you can land a great deal and feel good about the whole process.

Whether you’re gearing up to buy your first home or your fifth, I’ve got your back—and I’ll make sure you walk away with the keys and a win.


Ready to get started or have questions? Let’s talk.
Reach out anytime—no pressure, just real advice from your local real estate guy.


— Just Jack

October 5, 2025
What You Didn’t Ask / What They Didn’t Tell You You didn’t ask: “Can I negotiate more than just the price?” They didn’t tell you: Yes. Smart buyers also negotiate closing costs, home warranties, repairs, rate buydowns, and even appliances or furniture. The list price is just the beginning. The real savings often hide in the fine print. Just Jack – Trueblood Real Estate www.JustJack.Realtor 317-341-2474
By jcrenshaw October 5, 2025
Your Cheapest Option Could Be the Most Expensive
More Posts